The MCQ Generation - Do Our Examinations Discourage the Creativity We Claim to Value?
Some personal reflections on MCQs, higher education, and what we may be missing when we focus too much on the right answers.
Over the years, the more I have seen how students are taught and assessed, the more I have wondered whether our examination systems sometimes do exactly that. Perhaps not deliberately, but gradually, and in ways that we may not even notice.
This is not just about schools. I see the same concern in higher education, where multiple-choice questions (MCQs) and tick-marked answers are becoming increasingly common. And I cannot help asking myself: Are we becoming better at measuring students, or are we actually helping them learn better?
Let me explain what I mean.
When getting the right answer becomes more important than understanding the Concept
Having taught computing and software-related subjects in higher education for many years, I have seen how differently students approach learning depending on how they are assessed.
When students know that their marks depend largely on selecting the correct answer from a set of options, they naturally focus on finding that answer. They learn to recognise the right option, remember important facts, practise questions and avoid mistakes.
There is nothing wrong with any of that. MCQs have their place, and a well-designed question can test quite a bit of conceptual understanding.
But what happens when this becomes the main way students are assessed?
Do they still feel the same motivation to understand a concept deeply, draw a diagram to explain it, connect it to something they already know, or spend extra time figuring out why something works the way it does?
I sometimes feel that the emphasis has gradually shifted from understanding something well to getting the answer right somehow.
And these are not necessarily the same thing.
A student might correctly identify the answer to a question about an algorithm but struggle to explain how the algorithm works. Another might recognise the correct explanation of a statistical concept but find it difficult to apply that concept to a new problem.
The tick mark tells us that the student selected the expected answer. It does not always tell us how deeply the student understands it.
What happened to explaining things in our own words?
I remember my years at a university where MCQs were either absent from many of our assessments or used only sparingly. Much of the assessment involved students writing their answers in their own words.
As teachers, we had to read those answers carefully and make a genuine effort to understand what the students were trying to say.
Some students were not particularly strong in English. Their sentences could be awkward, their grammar imperfect, and their explanations sometimes difficult to follow at first glance. We were instructed to look beyond those linguistic mistakes and assess the student's actual understanding of the technical or management topic.
I remember how painstaking that process could be. We had to read, interpret, compare the explanation with the question, and decide whether the student really understood what they were writing about.
It took time and effort.
But there was a good reason for doing it.
We were trying to assess what the student knew, rather than simply how well they could express themselves in English.
Sometimes, an answer that initially looked poorly written contained a perfectly reasonable explanation. A student might not use the exact words found in a textbook, but the underlying idea could be correct. Another student might describe a concept through an example or a diagram that showed a genuine understanding of it.
These answers deserved to be recognised.And this is where I believe descriptive assessment has a value that is difficult to replace completely with tick-marked questions. It gives students room to express what they understand in their own way.
Of course, written answers can also encourage memorisation. A student can reproduce a textbook paragraph without understanding it. That is why we need thoughtful questions, not simply long answers for the sake of writing more.
The point is to give students opportunities to explain, reason, demonstrate and apply what they have learnt.
And then there is the viva voce
I have always felt that the viva voce, or oral examination, has an important place in education.
There is something revealing about asking a student a question and then following up with another question based on the answer.You can ask them to explain a concept differently, give an example, draw a diagram, or consider what would happen if one condition changed. You can explore an idea that was not explicitly covered in the original question.
A student who has memorised an answer may struggle when the conversation moves in an unexpected direction. A student who genuinely understands the subject may be able to reason through the problem, even if they do not immediately know the answer.
Naturally, a viva is not perfect. Some students become nervous when speaking in front of an examiner, and the examiner's own judgement can influence the outcome. Oral examinations therefore need clear criteria, fair questions and a consistent approach.
Still, they offer something valuable: an opportunity to explore a student's understanding through an actual conversation.
And surely that is an important part of learning?
Why are MCQs becoming so popular?
I can understand the attraction.
When an institution has thousands of students sitting examinations, evaluating every answer manually becomes a massive task. It takes time, costs money and requires many people. Different examiners may also interpret an answer differently, even when they are trying to be fair.
MCQs offer an obvious practical advantage. Answers can be scored quickly, sometimes automatically. Every student answering the same question can be marked against the same key. Results can be processed at a scale that would be difficult to manage with lengthy descriptive answers alone.
In this digital learning era, the attraction is even greater. Online examinations, automated scoring and rapid result processing make objective tests particularly convenient.
I have been following discussions on this issue, including a recent Facebook Live interview with the Director of IIT Kharagpur. He reportedly mentioned encountering students who had passed examinations without even stepping into the laboratory. He also spoke about the difficulties of manually checking the enormous number of answer scripts.
I found that observation particularly thought-provoking.
If a student passes an examination without ever performing the laboratory work that the subject is supposed to teach, what exactly has the examination established?
The student may know the theory. They may even answer questions about the experiment correctly. But have they demonstrated that they can actually perform it, observe what happens, interpret the results and understand the practical difficulties involved?
These are different things.
Similar concerns about examinations, conceptual understanding and the pressure to produce measurable results have also been raised in discussions involving IIT leadership.
I do not know whether MCQs are formally required in these situations, and I would not make that claim without evidence. But I do wonder whether the sheer scale of our education system creates an incentive to favour whatever can be assessed quickly and cheaply.
If we have to educate and examine enormous numbers of students every year, the temptation to simplify assessment is understandable.
The question is whether we are simplifying it too much.
Are we allowing the convenience of checking answer scripts to influence what we consider worth learning?
The problem is not MCQs. It is the imbalance.
Let me be clear. I am not suggesting that we should abandon multiple-choice questions.
They can be useful for checking factual knowledge, identifying misconceptions, testing conceptual distinctions and assessing certain kinds of problem-solving. They can also provide quick feedback to students and teachers.
My concern is what happens when one method begins to dominate the entire assessment process.
Personally, I would like to see three components given equal weight in a balanced assessment system:
MCQs: To test knowledge, recognition and selected aspects of conceptual understanding.
Written descriptive answers: To assess explanation, reasoning, diagrams, problem-solving and the ability to express ideas independently.
Viva voce: To explore understanding through questions, discussion, follow-up explanations and spontaneous reasoning.
Each component would contribute one-third of the final assessment.
The exact balance could be adjusted for different subjects. In engineering, science and computing, practical work should also be assessed directly wherever it is an essential learning outcome. A laboratory course cannot be properly assessed by asking students only to select the correct answer about an experiment.
Similarly, a course that develops communication or presentation skills should provide opportunities to demonstrate those skills.
The underlying principle is simple: students should have more than one way to demonstrate what they know and can do.
No single method can capture every aspect of learning. A balanced approach can also reduce the risk of one examination format determining a student's entire academic outcome.
Of course, descriptive answers need fair marking schemes, and viva voce examinations need safeguards against personal bias. But these are challenges to address, not reasons to abandon richer forms of assessment altogether.
Are we rewarding the wrong kind of effort?
This is the part that concerns me most as a teacher.
Students are practical. They know that marks matter. Their grades influence progression, opportunities and, eventually, employment. So they pay attention to what the examination rewards.
If they discover that drawing a detailed diagram, explaining an idea in their own words or exploring an alternative solution makes little difference to their marks, while selecting the correct option does, what do we expect them to prioritise?
Many will concentrate on what gives them the best return for their effort.
I cannot blame them for that.
Why should a student spend an extra hour trying to understand the deeper workings of a concept if the examination does not reward that effort? Why should they practise explaining an idea in their own words if recognising a familiar answer is enough to pass?
Some students will remain naturally curious. They will explore, experiment and ask questions regardless of how they are assessed.
But should our education system depend on individual curiosity surviving despite the incentives we create?
I believe that if we want students to think deeply, we must make room for that thinking in our assessments. If we want them to develop their own explanations, we must ask questions that require explanations. If we want them to become problem-solvers, we must give them problems that cannot always be solved by recognising a familiar option.
And if we want creativity, we must be willing to recognise answers that demonstrate sound thinking even when they do not follow a single expected pattern.
This takes me back to Sir Ken Robinson
Whenever I think about these issues, I am reminded of Sir Ken Robinson and his famous talk, Do Schools Kill Creativity?
His argument was not simply that schools should include more art or encourage children to be imaginative. He questioned an education system that tends to value certain kinds of ability while neglecting others, and that can gradually narrow the ways students learn to think and express themselves.
I find that argument relevant far beyond school education.
In higher education, we often talk about critical thinking, creativity, innovation, independent learning and problem-solving. These qualities appear in course outcomes, programme objectives and institutional statements.
But how much do our assessments actually reward them?
We may tell students to think independently, but then give them examinations that primarily reward the recognition of predetermined answers.
We may encourage them to explore different approaches, but assess them against a narrow answer key.
We may speak about innovation, but provide limited opportunities to demonstrate how they arrived at an idea or why they believe it might work.
There seems to be a contradiction here.
We cannot consistently tell students to think beyond the textbook while rewarding them mainly for selecting the answer already printed in front of them.
That does not mean every MCQ encourages shallow learning. Nor does it mean every descriptive examination encourages deep thinking. The questions themselves matter enormously.
But if we want creativity and independent thought to flourish, our assessment methods must support those goals rather than work against them.
What kind of graduates do we really want?
Ultimately, this is not just a debate about examinations. It is about the kind of graduates we hope our universities will produce.
Do we want graduates who can recognise the right answer when it is presented to them? Certainly.
But we also need graduates who can investigate a problem for which they do not already have an answer, explain their reasoning to others, draw connections between ideas, learn from mistakes and come up with solutions that nobody has handed them.
These abilities matter in research, technology, management and almost every field where people are expected to create something new or deal with unfamiliar situations.
Innovation rarely begins with four options neatly arranged on a screen.
It often begins with a question, an observation, a failed attempt, a rough sketch or an idea that initially seems unusual. It requires the freedom to explore possibilities before knowing which one will work.
If our students become too accustomed to searching for the correct option, will they feel equally comfortable when they have to formulate the question themselves?
I do not have a definitive answer. But I think it is a question worth asking.
A final thought
I understand the challenges faced by universities. Large student numbers, limited resources, examination schedules and the need for consistent grading are real problems. Teachers cannot spend unlimited hours evaluating every answer, and institutions need assessment systems that are practical and fair.
But education should not be designed around administrative convenience alone.
Perhaps we need to step back and ask ourselves what an examination is actually supposed to do. Is it merely a mechanism for sorting students, assigning grades and processing results? Or is assessment also an opportunity to discover what students understand, where they struggle and how they think?
I believe it should be both.
MCQs have a place. Written answers have a place. Viva voce examinations have a place. Practical demonstrations have a place. The challenge is to use each method where it adds value, rather than allowing the easiest method to become the dominant one.
After all, the purpose of education is not simply to help students find the right answers.
It is to help them develop the knowledge, confidence and curiosity to ask better questions, explore unfamiliar ideas and sometimes discover answers that nobody had thought of before.
And that brings me back to Sir Ken Robinson.
If we genuinely value creativity, perhaps we should start by looking at the way we assess learning.
Are our examinations helping students become independent thinkers, or teaching them to become better at ticking the right box?
What do you think? 👇
I'd be interested to hear from teachers, educators, lecturers, academic leaders and other education professionals who have experience with these issues. If you have a different perspective, a classroom experience, or an approach that has worked for you, please feel free to share it in the comments.
Thoughtful disagreement is welcome too. The aim is to learn from one another and keep the conversation going. Thank you!
- Robinson, K. (2006). Do Schools Kill Creativity? TED2006. Video and transcript.
- Robinson, K. Out of Our Minds: The Power of Being Creative. Official book page.
- The Indian Express (6 April 2026). “‘Coaching culture trains students to game exams, not build concepts’: IIT Bombay Director Shireesh Kedare at Idea Exchange.” Full interview.
- Bengali Facebook Live interview with Professor Suman Chakraborty, Director of IIT Kharagpur Original interview (Bengali) - Facebook login required; English Translation - Transcript (channel: https://www.facebook.com/arijitofficialpage/re/ )





Comments
Post a Comment